The Texans lead the league with players on IR with 16. By the end of the year last year, they led the league too. This weekend against the Bucs, Texans starting quarterback Matt Schaub isn't expected to play due to a dislocated non-throwing arm, and will be replaced by backup Sage Rosenfels. There's a good video of Rosenfels talking about the start here. His backup is Shane Boyd, a midseason pickup who has never played a game with the Texans.
Rosenfels is a smart quarterback his teammates like and trust, and can sling the ball. He also tends to throw interceptions at inopportune times. Some fantasy players might be tempted to pick him up for the end of the season because the Texans have been able to pass the ball with Rosenfels, but the Texans are facing some tough pass defenses in the weeks ahead.
Running back Ahman Green suffered a bruised knee in week 1 of the season against Kansas City, and has struggled to come back from it. He practiced on Wednesday for the first time in a while and Gary Kubiak says he's optimistic.
Optimistic in Kubiak-speak means "Hey I am an upbeat guy by nature. Of course, this tells you nothing about whether he will play." If Green can't go, at some point he is going to go on IR to make room for someone who can get on the field.
Kubiak says that running back Ron Dayne suffered a twisted ankle last week but should be expected to play. Ideally, with only one healthy experienced QB, the Texans would like to run the ball a lot down the stretch like they did last year, but I am not sure physically they will be able to do it.
So basically, the Texans have four running backs to choose from. One has been injured for most the season, one is nicked up and two are very inexperienced. They will be running behind a line that will play the backup to the backup at the right guard position, and they haven't figured out who that guy is going to be. If Rosenfels goes out due to injury, a practice squad guy who wasn't with the team in camp is going to fill in. Oh. Joy.
The rest of this season isn't as much about wins and losses but rather learning and survival. They need this time to get their young players experience and hope no more of them get fluky horrible injuries that will harm them in future years.
Any more thoughts on this?











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-06-2007 @ 9:27PM
donkeykong said...
I believe you have to play to win, and not just to learn and survive. If the Browns or Titans win their games next week, then you can quit playing to win. Giving up now is too early and sends a bad message. Sage, besides having a cool name, needs a chance to play with the best, most experienced players available to the Texans. Sage can be the best QB on the Texans, and is more durable. Your starter needs to be durable because other players must adjust to him from small things like his cadence to timing routes. He played the Titans very well for a backup. You must ignore sunk costs.
Reply
12-06-2007 @ 9:36PM
Stephanie Stradley said...
dk-
I am not suggesting that they should tank it. Certainly, winning is a part of learning. But as fans, I think at this point the best thing that can happen is surviving the season without any more of the promising players on this team going down to injury.
It's hard to build a franchise when your solid players keep getting injured. Hopefully, we will get to see if some of the young backups can play ball--there's some difficult games ahead.
Thanks for your comments,
Steph
P.S. Hard to say at this point in their respective careers that Sage is more durable. Schaub got cheap-shotted some, and Sage probably would have played last season had he not had his own freak injury with his broken hand on a special teams tackle. Just a thought.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 10:38AM
James Martin said...
Steph, what is your take on the Texans leading the league in players on Injured Reserve for the last 2 years in a row.
Is it bad luck?
The way they prepare during training camp and during the week?
I understand injuries are a part of the game, it just seems that the last 2 seasons injuries are a disturbing trend that is developing under this new regime.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 12:18PM
Fran said...
Steph,
Please explain for me (and others) the difference between IR and PUP. Charles Spencer has been on the PUP list since before the season started. Could if (if able) come back this year?
I have wondered what Physically Unable to Play really means.
Fran
P.S. Glad to see you are back. I thought you might be too discouraged to even write again!
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 12:18PM
Justin said...
I think it's time go get a durable QB and RB. I'm not taking nothing away from Schaub or Green but, it's crazy that these two can't stay healthy for some reason.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 1:17PM
Stephanie Stradley said...
James-
Some of the IR stuff is bad luck, but they are going to have to really look at this during the offseason.
Fran-
If a player gets put on IR, he can't play for the rest of the season. Here's how it is distinguished from PUP:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physically_Unable_to_Perform
The key thing to remember is if a player starts the season at training camp on the active roster, they cannot be designated PUP.
Spencer could have come back this year if he was okay, but he wasn't right yet.
BTW, the way we assign games at FanHouse is that we cover the home games of the teams we are assigned and usually not the road games unless someone needs some help. So you will get a lot of my writing for this game and the next.
Justin-
Injuries happen in the NFL. Green unfortunately got hurt game one and has been really trying to come back. With Schaub, he got some pretty questionable hits that made him miss games. It's too early to tell what his long term durability will be.
Thanks all for reading and commenting,
Steph
Reply