Just for fun, we're going to rank each real NFL team as if they were a fantasy football team. The question is quite simple, who would sport the best squad in fantasyland if you needed a QB, two running backs, two receivers, a tight end, a defense/special teams, kicker, and a flex player?This is also a cheap ploy -- but not as cheap as the free fantasy leagues on fleaflicker -- to link every single team preview (just click on the team name).
Just check out the Colts' fantasy starting lineup, it's disgusting. Peyton Manning, Joseph Addai, Dominic Rhodes, Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, Dallas Clark, a quality defensive unit, Adam Vinatieri, and Anthony Gonzalez. Wow. I'm sure to hear complaints from Cowboys, Chargers, and Patriots fans here, but you can't run out a better lineup, using this criteria, than Indy. If you played in a 14-team league and had a replacement for Rhodes, this lineup gets you to the playoffs.
Counting Down the Top 10
No. 10 - Cincinnati Bengals
Key Fantasy Options: Carson Palmer, T.J. Houshmandzadeh (pictured), Chad Johnson, Rudi Johnson
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
David Kohl, AP
No. 9 - New Orleans Saints
Key Fantasy Options: Drew Brees, Marques Colston (pictured), Reggie Bush, Deuce McAllister, Jeremy Shockey, Robert Meachem
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Alex Brandon, AP
No. 8 - Cleveland Browns
Key Fantasy Options: Jamal Lewis, Braylon Edwards (pictured), Derek Anderson, Kellen Winslow, Donte' Stallworth
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Tony Dejak, AP
No. 7 - New York Giants
Key Fantasy Options: Brandon Jacobs (pictured), Plaxico Burress, Eli Manning, Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
David Drapkin, Getty Images
No. 6 - Pittsburgh Steelers
Key Fantasy Options: Ben Roethlisberger, Willie Parker, Santonio Holmes, Heath Miller, Rashard Mendenhall (pictured), Hines Ward, Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Keith Srakocic, AP
No. 5 - Green Bay Packers
Key Fantasy Options: Ryan Grant (pictured), Greg Jennings, Aaron Rodgers, Donald Driver, Donald Lee, Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Andy Manis, AP
No. 4 - Dallas Cowboys
Key Fantasy Options: Marion Barber III (pictured), Tony Romo, Terrell Owens, Jason Witten, Patrick Crayton, Felix Jones, Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Matt Slocum, AP
No. 3 - San Diego Chargers
Key Fantasy Options: LaDainian Tomlinson, Antonio Gates, Philip Rivers, Chris Chambers (pictured), Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Winslow Townson, AP
No. 2 - New England Patriots
Key Fantasy Options: Tom Brady, Randy Moss, Laurence Maroney, Wes Welker (pictured), Benjamin Watson, Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Michael Dwyer, AP
No. 1 - Indianapolis Colts
Key Fantasy Options: Joseph Addai (pictured), Peyton Manning, Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, Anthony Gonzalez, Dallas Clark, Defensive Unit
See Full Preview From Draft Kit
Stephan Savoia, AP
The three aforementioned teams have an argument, but each has at least one hole. The Cowboys, for example, run out Patrick Crayton at the WR2 slot, and the flex guy is whomever wins the WR3 job. The Chargers have similar issues, with Vincent Jackson as the WR2 and the flex in flux. The Pats have either Lamont Jordan, Sammy Morris, or Kevin Faulk as the RB2.
Without further ado, let's rank 'em ...
1. Colts -- The buck stops here. I already wrote out the starting lineup. Not only that, but Mike Hart is a very sleepy option going into the season as he'll win the third-string running back job. I said it in the preview, anyone can accrue stats from the running back position in this offense.
2. Patriots -- It's hard to go wrong here, but the Colts do have a decided advantage over these boys at tight end and running back No. 2. The difference between Wes Welker and Marvin Harrison isn't enough to offset those positions, especially with Anthony Gonzalez being a much better flex than Jabar Gaffney.
3. Chargers -- As you saw in the preview, I love this squad. If you were making a fantasy team, though, they'd be top heavy. LaDanian Tomlinson, Antonio Gates, and the defense are elite, while Philip Rivers and Chris Chambers are quality options. After that, though, the stock of this team plummets. You could argue that the three elite units pick up the slack of the lesser starters. Either way, the team is awesome.
4. Cowboys -- I bet if you went through mock draft forms and did some analysis on where players were being drafted, the 'boys would challenge the Colts for the top spot. They are easily the most overrated team in fantasy this season. Brinson has covered how overvalued Tony Romo is twice, I'm anti-T.O., and the defense isn't top three (it's being picked that way). Hell, I even saw Marion Barber drafted second overall in one draft -- which was fine with me because I was able to get Adrian Peterson from the three-hole. All this being said, overrated doesn't mean they aren't good. This team is damn good.
5. Packers -- As I said in the preview, this is a fantasy paradise. Aaron Rodgers will do enough to keep the receivers very valuable, and Ryan Grant's holdout only made Brandon Jackson that much stronger an option. Receiver goes four deep, the tight end is strong, and the defense is elite.
6. Steelers -- Not one weak spot, when you consider the additions of Limas Sweed and Rashard Mendenhall via the draft. They are separated from the top group only because of the absence of truly elite players.
7. Giants -- The Champs are quite loaded as well, with three usable running backs, and quality options at every position.
8. Browns -- Thin at running back, and the defense still has to prove that the changes will help transform things positively. Everywhere else, though, the Brownies are stellar.
9. Saints -- Adding Jeremy Shockey made the offense even more high-octane. Drew Brees and Marques Colston are very solid picks considering they get overshadowed by others at their position.
10. Bengals -- The passing attack contains three studly options (Carson Palmer, TJ Houshmandzadeh, and Chad Johnson), while the running game has two able-bodied players.
Latest NFL Photos
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: Sheldon Brown #24 (R) and Lorenzo Booker #25 of the Philadelphia Eagles take down Muhsin Muhammad #87 of the Carolina Panthers during the NFL game at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Lorenzo Booker;Sheldon Brown;Muhsin Muhammad
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: Brian Dawkins #20 of the Philadelphia Eagles collides with Muhsin Muhammad #87 of the Carolina Panthers during the NFL game at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images)
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: Donovan McNabb #5 of the Philadelphia Eagles looks for an open man during the NFL game against the Carolina Panthers at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Donovan McNabb
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: Donovan McNabb #5 talks with Andy Reid, head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles during the NFL game against the Carolina Panthers at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Andy Reid;Donovan McNabb
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: Jake Delhomme #17 of the Carolina Panthers talks to Lito Sheppard #26 of the Philadelphia Eagles during the NFL game at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Jake Delhomme;Lito Sheppard
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: A Philadelphia Eagles cheerleader performs in the rain during the NFL game against the Carolina Panthers at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images)
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: DeAngelo Williams #34 leaps over Keydrick Vincent #68 of the Carolina Panthers as Juqua Parker #75 Philadelphia Eagles closes in during the NFL game at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Keydrick Vincent;DeAngelo Williams;Juqua Parker
Getty Images
PHILADELPHIA - AUGUST 14: DeAngelo Williams #34 (R) of the Carolina Panthers evades Lito Sheppard #26 Philadelphia Eagles as Muhsin Muhammad #87 of the Carolina Panthers provides coverage during the NFL game at Lincoln Financial Field on August 14, 2008 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Muhsin Muhammad;DeAngelo Williams;Lito Sheppard
Getty Images
Philadelphia Eagles' Quintin Demps (39) tackles Carolina Panthers' Decori Birmingham (26) during the forth quarter of an NFL preseason football game in Philadelphia, Thursday, Aug. 14, 2008. The Eagles won 24-13. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)
AP
Philadelphia Eagles' Greg Lewis catches a touchdown pass during the fourth quarter of an NFL preseason football game against the Carolina Panthers in Philadelphia, Thursday, Aug. 14, 2008. The Eagles won 24-13. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)
AP
11. Seahawks -- Quality all-around, without anything really spectacular. I do love the defense and think it's very underrated.
12. Eagles -- Many things went poorly last year, Brian Westbrook excepted. The defense and Donovan McNabb will bounce back.
13. Rams -- It wasn't long ago that you would have seen them ranked first or second. Still some lingering play-makers from the Greatest Show. They'll have a big bounce-back year.
14. Redskins -- The new offense is a much better fit for Jason Campbell and Clinton Portis ... and the receiving corps is now loaded with young talent after that draft.
15. Jaguars -- Questions at receiver, but nowhere else. The only problem is they aren't elite anywhere, just solid. Reggie Williams' injury is a blow to an already thin receiving group.
16. Jets -- Now that the QB situation is solved with Favre in town, you've gotta give Thomas Jones and the receivers a big bump up.
17. Vikings -- Not awful, despite the fact that it's all running and defense. Adrian Peterson has to count for something, right?
18. Bills -- A team full of sleepers. Marshawn Lynch, Trent Edwards, Lee Evans, James Hardy, and the defense should all be great value picks this season.
19. Broncos -- Already thin at wideout, now they lose Brandon Marshall for three games. Selvin Young could be a stud, but will Mike Shanahan let him?
20. Panthers -- Steve Smith is going to be out two games, but other than that there's a lot to like on this underrated offense.
21. Cardinals -- Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Boldin make this team, because they ultimately create a good QB of anyone throwing to them. Edgerrin James, however, is on his last legs and doesn't really have a viable backup.
22. Texans -- Matt Schaub to Andre Johnson is a potentially prolific tandem. With Gary Kubiak at the helm, this team will run the football ... but do you count on Ahman Green? Chris Brown? Chris Taylor or Steve Slaton?
23. 49ers -- Mike Martz showed up so everyone loves these guys. Alex Smith still scares me, as does the age of Isaac Bruce. You do have Frank Gore and a quality sleeper in Bryant Johnson.
24. Ravens -- Things will be interesting this year at QB, but interesting doesn't garner fantasy points. Avoid the passing attack and rely on the running game.
25. Titans -- A whole lotta vanilla here, but they do have a quality second running back in rookie speedster Chris Johnson.
26. Raiders -- Darren McFadden and JaMarcus Russell? Love it. Everything else? Not so much.
27. Bucs -- I'm not buying anyone here to exceed expectations ... and they aren't that high from a fantasy standpoint.
28. Lions -- Unfortunately, the departure of fantasy sweetheart Mike Martz takes away the most desirable fantasy cog here. They are going to concentrate more on the run, with a third-round draftee and Tatum Bell.
29. Bears -- Kevin Jones has been added to the mix since I wrote the fantasy preview, but this is still mostly a scrap heap. There's upside in Matt Forte, Devin Hester, and even Rex Grossman; but this is still only a kicking and defense fantasy bastion.
30. Falcons -- It's gonna be a long season.
31. Chiefs -- Larry Johnson isn't "LJ" anymore. Tony Gonzalez isn't Tony Gonzalez anymore (though he is a super hero). Of course, Brodie Croyle is still Brodie Croyle.
32. Dolphins -- Running back Ronnie Brown was an elite player last year before injury. Let's hope he returns to form, or else the team will completely embarrass itself week in, week out.
Ready to join the fun against fellow football fans? Sign up for FREE and EASY Fantasy Football with Fleaflicker.com.
Get Your Own Team Today!











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
8-15-2008 @ 2:12PM
daniel said...
I think you are slightly wrong. Yes some guys on the Cowboys are overrated but how can you use Romo and TO as an example of that? Barber yes perhaps, but not Romo or TO. Romo shattered franchise records and TO is one the top recievers in the NFL. I can only put Moss and maybe Fitzgerald ahead of him. Romo is also was an undrafted free agent who came out of no where! Look at the first round pick Vince Young, that guy is awful! I agree with you on the defense, I believe it may be top 5 but not top 3. In conclusion, lay off Romo and TO, they are what their numbers prove, PRO BOWLERS!
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 7:28PM
s0 cal said...
CoWbOyS, 1 and only, america's team. and people want to talk trash? they have a GUARENTEED SUPERBOWL ring within the next 3 years-jerry jones is getting old and he will spare no expence to see that happen before he dies. GO COWBOYS!
8-15-2008 @ 2:20PM
Tim said...
eagles cowboys and redskins suck...giants all the way!!
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:00PM
Jerry said...
Giants will not make the playoffs this year last year was just a an accident
8-15-2008 @ 3:33PM
real cowboys fan said...
keep on wishing the cowboys are easy the best team in the nfc and by the end of the year best in the nfl.
8-15-2008 @ 2:22PM
Bill Sweetnam said...
The Cowboys won't help you at all in Fantasy Football.
Oh yeah, and my brother-in-law Jay Bock is a criminal.
Two ABSOLUTE facts you can rely upon.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 2:28PM
Matt Snyder said...
Maybe I wasn't clear enough when I ranked the Cowboys 4th or put:
"All this being said, overrated doesn't mean they aren't good. This team is damn good."
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 5:28PM
Mattdawg said...
You better just make that #1, their Snyder too much talent for one team
8-15-2008 @ 2:58PM
MW said...
Lion Haters
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 2:48PM
nate said...
Apparently Matt Snyder Mr. writer man didnt have T.O. on his squad last year. Obviously he is very biased against the boys. The Cowboys will have the best defense this year if you just look at player potential and ranking in each position. I think the Colts are a solid team under his "fantasy" model BUT the Patriots and the Chargers?? Brady, Moss and L.T. would make a good fantasy team...but the patriots have no running game to speak of last year, and the chargers have no QB or proven receivers .....whatever Matt, put your silver and blue hater-aide down.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 2:44PM
Randy said...
The Giants are a young,talented team yet they are rated #7?. How can the Cowboys or any team in the NFC East be rated ahead of them?. They are ascending while proving they are a new power in the NFL. Its so tough to repeat as Super Bowl champs. You need the hunger,no key injuries and hope that you do not lose too many key players because of your supreme success(only Shockey who they won without). But the Giants have young talent and top draft picks safety Kenny Philips and cb Terrell Thomas have been exceptional. Great defensive and offensive lines with a top QB are the keys to being top shelf. Why are the Giants not in the top 4?
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 2:46PM
Matt Snyder said...
Because these are fantasy football team rankings, not actual team rankings.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 2:54PM
J said...
FANTASY FOOTBALL ? ? ? ? ? What the H is that all about. Must be some pretty well $$$$ off people out there with nothing better to do. Give me the real thing, always
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:03PM
Fryer said...
The 'Boys have some talent, but they're definitely overrated. Last year, they were a 10-6 team that lucked into a 13-3 record. I expect more of the same this year.
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:39PM
Real cowboys fan said...
the cowboys are the best team in the nfl live with it and stop the hate
8-15-2008 @ 3:09PM
jodaddy said...
RAMS WILL COME PLAYOFFS
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:10PM
andrew said...
Mr Snyder, first of all let me say, it's not very smart for a no name sports writer to trash the Cowboys (the most popular team in the country). Romo and T.O. overrated? Give me one piece of evidence to back up that statement Mr. sports writer. Oh wait, you can't. Keep putting this stuff out and you'll stay a writer for the "AOL fanhouse." GO COWBOYS!!!!
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 6:41PM
ME said...
COWBOYS best team ever??? T.O? Really??? Mmmmmmmml let me see!! Holds the RECORD for the most DROPPED passes in the NFL!!!!! Yeah that's just great!! Let's pay someone TONS of money to Drop everything that isn't thrown right in his hands!!
8-15-2008 @ 3:24PM
barry said...
saints should be in the top 5 wait and see
Reply
8-15-2008 @ 3:45PM
Chris said...
WOW does it really say the steelers dont have one weak spot??? How about that aging defense that isnt what it used to be. The defense is getting by on what they did years ago. Anyone who watched them last year can see its decline. Steelers arent even a top 10 team in my opinion.
By the way im from Pa but i love how everyone hates on the cowboys. So called experts love to hate on them, then all during the year you get to watch them flip flop worse the hillary clinton. After a loss they down them, after a win they are the greatest thing since sliced bread. Quit hating on the team and give them a fair assessment.
Reply